Book Review: The Hundred Years’ War: Modern War Poems edited by Neil Astley

modern war poems‘There is nothing one man will not do to another.’ (The Visitor, Carolyn Forché)

On 7th January 1915 the war in Europe was at a stalemate. Soldiers were still dying for an unknown cause but the papers in the UK at least, were headlined with floods that covered much of the country. On the following day, the future UK Prime Minister David Lloyd George, in response to the war not ‘being over by Christmas’, said that half a million new volunteers should not be ‘thrown away in futile enterprises’ and by ‘this intermittent flinging …. against impregnable positions’.

‘Tumbling over hills, likes waves of the sea/Staggering on, attracted magnetically by Death.’ (At the Beginning of the War, Peter Baum, 1915)

On 7th January 2015 twelve people were killed by terrorists in Paris, almost 100 killed and maimed on the streets of Sanaa, and, although not known on the day, hundreds were being slaughtered by Boko Haram in Nigeria. And of course there were ongoing deaths caused by the war in Syria, Iraq, Afghanistan, and continued instability in Libya. One hundred years of wars, still raging in an age of  supposed modernity.

‘Down in the barn/a shell came crashing/like the hopes of all the years collapsing.’ (Wildfire, Albert-Paul Granier, 1914).

Neil-Astley-007So it is sad but unsurprising that the latest anthology of poems from the great editor Neil Astley of Bloodaxe runs to around four hundred and twenty poems, and there could have been many more (e.g. I don’t think there are any about Rwanda). You almost wish there were fewer poems simply as a reflection of fewer wars.

‘What are they looking for,/running to the summit of lost time?/Hundreds of people vaporised instantly/are walking in mid-air.’ (The Myth of Hiroshima, Nobuyuki Saga)

The anthology takes us through the major conflicts of the last hundred years; Eric Hobsbawm described the 20th century as the most murderous in recorded history. Beginning with 1914 probably the most well-known set of poems about the First World War and taking us right up to the new forms of war that we see on the streets of major capitals and in such paradoxical internationalised civil conflicts as Syria.

‘One man to five. A million men to one./And still they die. And still the war goes on.’ (Cambodia, James Fenton)

Neil writes a concise and insightful one-pager for each war, covering the conflict itself and the response of poets to it. And there is the chilling figure of the number of deaths for each one. Common I think to many of these conflicts is the disproportionate losses of working class lives, whether in the First World War as soldiers, or the Second World War as civilians.

‘every day has its breast outraged by the bullets/which like lightning-strike smashed the innocent/back against the wall.’ (For the Martyrs of Loreto Square, Alfonso Gatto)

Many of the poets were/are directly involved, either as soldiers, journalists, photographers, or civilians. And so there is a good range of perspectives and spread of nationalities. Most recent of all, Dan O’Brien wrote a powerful collection based on the information given him by the ‘War Reporter Paul Watson’.

‘Chunks of corpses rain down/like volcanic cinders. Wind sprints, senseless/shouts. The assassin has taken several/out with the chief, and everyone’s wounded/who survives.’ (The War Reporter Paul Watson and the Chief’s Embrace, Dan O’Brien)

For me, the wars in the Middle East and Northern Ireland (the latter euphemistically called ‘The Troubles’), were particularly resonant. I also learned a great deal about other conflicts such as The Spanish Civil War and the Korean War. But it was to the last section, the current conflicts, that I was initially drawn to and will stay with me longest; for I have not doubt, that section, which is one of the smaller sections of the book, will tragically soon be expanding.

‘How terrified I am by the eyes of the terrified,/Everyone who’s terrified, terrifies.’ (A Solider in a Madhouse, Golan Haji)

Death Tolls
First World War, 1914-18 – 37 million
Ireland, 1916-1923 – 4,000-6,000
Spanish Civil War 1936-39 – 500,000
Second World War, 1939-55 – 78 million
Korean War, 1950-53 – More than 2 million
The Cold War, 1947-91 – Unknown
Vietnam War, 1956-75 – 1 million to 3.8 million
Israel, Palestine, Lebanon, 1947-present – Highly contested
The Troubles, 1966-99 – 3,636
Yugoslav Wars of Succession, 1991-99 – More than 140,000
Iraq Wars, 1980-2011 – Up to 1.5 million
Afghanistan, 1980-present – c1.75 million
Worldwide War, 1970-present – Unknown

‘Go tell those old men, safe in bed/We took their orders and are dead.’ (Inscription for a War, A.D. Hope)

The Hundred Years’ War: Modern War Poems. Edited by Neil Astley (Bloodaxe Books, 2014)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s